What to ask for — the gaps worth exposing
- Crash history at a "goldmine" camera — the 5-year crash record at a specific high-revenue camera site, to test whether it's a blackspot or a trap (see Goldmines).
- The contractor's payment model — how the private camera operator is actually paid (per hour vs per fine), and the contract value (see Contracts).
- Error & withdrawal rates — how many camera fines were reviewed, withdrawn or refunded, and the false-positive rate (see Errors).
- Road-safety fund spending — how much of the hypothecated fund was collected vs actually spent (the underspend, see The Money).
- Marketing spend — the advertising/campaign budget vs fine revenue (the propaganda ratio, see The Strategy).
Template 1 — Camera siting & crash history
Tests the "cameras go where the crashes are" claim. Address it to your state road agency / police (NSW: Transport for NSW or Revenue NSW; VIC: Dept of Justice & Community Safety; QLD: Transport & Main Roads).
To the FOI/GIPA Officer,
Under the [Government Information (Public Access) Act 2009 (NSW) /
Freedom of Information Act 1982 (Vic) / Right to Information Act 2009 (Qld) /
relevant FOI Act], I request access to the following information:
1. For the fixed/mobile speed or red-light camera located at
[ADDRESS / INTERSECTION], for the most recent 5 financial years:
(a) the number of infringements issued, by year;
(b) the total revenue raised, by year;
(c) the recorded casualty and fatal crash history at that location
for the 5 years BEFORE the camera was installed, and for each
year SINCE; and
(d) the site-selection justification / business case used to approve
the camera at that location.
I ask that documents be provided in electronic form. If any part is
refused, please cite the specific exemption and provide the balance.
[Name] [Contact details] [Date]
Template 2 — Contractor payment & contract terms
Tests the incentive to over-issue fines and the secrecy of the deals.
To the FOI/GIPA Officer, Under the [relevant FOI/GIPA Act], I request: 1. The current contract(s) between [agency] and the private operator(s) of the state's speed / red-light / mobile-phone detection cameras (e.g. Acusensus, Redflex/Verra Mobility, Serco, Jenoptik). 2. In particular, the clauses setting out HOW the operator is remunerated — specifically whether payment is per hour of enforcement, a fixed fee, or linked in any way to the number or value of infringements detected. 3. The total value of each such contract and its start and end dates. Where commercial-in-confidence is claimed, please release the payment- structure and total-value clauses with only genuinely commercial pricing detail redacted, and state the public-interest reasoning for any redaction. [Name] [Contact details] [Date]
Template 3 — Error, review & withdrawal rates
The number no one advertises: how often the "infallible" machine is wrong.
To the FOI/GIPA Officer, Under the [relevant FOI/GIPA Act], for each of the last 3 financial years, I request statistics showing, for camera-detected traffic infringements: 1. the total number of infringements issued; 2. the number for which a review was requested; 3. the number withdrawn, waived or refunded, and the total value; 4. for mobile-phone/seatbelt AI cameras: the number of images flagged by the system that were rejected at human review (i.e. the machine's false-positive count or rate); and 5. any internal report on camera accuracy, calibration failures or erroneously issued fines during the period. Electronic format preferred. [Name] [Contact details] [Date]
Template 4 — Road-safety fund underspend
Tests "it all goes back into road safety."
To the FOI/GIPA Officer, Under the [relevant FOI/GIPA Act], for each of the last 5 financial years, I request: 1. the total revenue paid INTO the [Community Road Safety Fund / Better Roads Victoria Trust / Road Trauma Trust Account / relevant fund] from camera and traffic fines; 2. the total amount actually SPENT from that fund each year; 3. the closing balance / accumulated unspent amount each year; and 4. a breakdown of what the spent money was spent on. Electronic format preferred. [Name] [Contact details] [Date]
Template 5 — The Community Road Safety Fund (the loop)
Prises open the self-funding loop on The Fund — how much comes in, how much is spent, and how much bankrolls more cameras and police. Send to accessapplications@transport.nsw.gov.au (Transport for NSW).
Send to: accessapplications@transport.nsw.gov.au (Transport for NSW) Subject: Informal access request (GIPA) — Community Road Safety Fund To the Access to Information / GIPA Officer, Under the Government Information (Public Access) Act 2009 (NSW), I request informal release of the following. If informal release is declined, please treat this as a formal access application and advise the $30 application fee. For each of the last 5 financial years: 1. Total revenue paid INTO the Community Road Safety Fund, broken down by source — fixed speed cameras, mobile speed cameras, red-light cameras, mobile-phone/seatbelt cameras, average/point-to-point cameras, and any allocation from the Consolidated Fund. 2. Total amount SPENT from the Fund each year, itemised by program — in particular the amounts spent on (a) police enforcement and (b) operating the automated camera enforcement program itself. 3. The closing balance / accumulated unspent amount at the end of each year. 4. Any amount transferred FROM the Fund back into the Consolidated Fund. Please provide documents in electronic form (a spreadsheet if available). [Your name] · [email or postal address] · [date]
Template 6 — ANPR retention & enforcement targets
Tests the surveillance grid: how long every plate is kept, who can see it, and whether police work to revenue targets. Lodge with NSW Police (online GIPA portal; enquiries iau@police.nsw.gov.au).
Send to: NSW Police Force — GIPA online portal (police.nsw.gov.au → "GIPA");
enquiries iau@police.nsw.gov.au ($30 formal application)
Subject: GIPA application — ANPR retention and camera enforcement
To the Information Access Unit,
Under the Government Information (Public Access) Act 2009 (NSW), I request:
1. For automatic number-plate recognition (ANPR): the number of plates
read/logged per year for the last 3 years; the retention period for
reads that do NOT match any alert ("non-hit" reads); the policy
governing who may access ANPR data; and any record of ANPR data being
accessed for a purpose other than vehicle-registration or traffic
enforcement (e.g. movement or location tracking).
2. For mobile speed cameras: the total contracted and actual HOURS of
enforcement per year for the last 3 years.
3. Any internal document that sets a revenue target, KPI, quota or
expected number of infringements for traffic or camera enforcement.
Electronic format preferred.
[Your name] · [contact] · [date]
Template 7 — The statistic they never publish
Goes to the heart of Speed: the isolated causal contribution of illegal speeding. Send to the Commonwealth department that houses BITRE — foi@infrastructure.gov.au (no fee; a plain email is enough).
Send to: foi@infrastructure.gov.au (Dept of Infrastructure / BITRE — no fee) Subject: FOI request — isolated causal contribution of illegal speeding To the FOI Coordinator, Under the Freedom of Information Act 1982 (Cth), I request access to any document, dataset or analysis held by the Department or by BITRE that: 1. quantifies the number or proportion of fatal or serious-injury crashes attributable specifically to a driver EXCEEDING THE POSTED SPEED LIMIT on a road that was otherwise compliant — as distinct from "travelling too fast for the conditions" (often at or below the limit), and as distinct from crashes primarily caused by alcohol, drugs, fatigue or distraction; and 2. sets out the methodology and definition by which a crash is classified as "speed-related" or "speeding-related" in national crash statistics. If no such document exists, I ask the Department to confirm that in writing. A plain electronic copy is fine. I'm happy to narrow scope to stay within any processing-charge threshold. [Your name] · [contact] · [date]
Template 8 — Camera tolerance & per-site crash history
The secret margin, and whether the top earners are blackspots or traps (see Speed, Goldmines). Send to accessapplications@transport.nsw.gov.au (Transport for NSW).
Send to: accessapplications@transport.nsw.gov.au (Transport for NSW) Subject: Informal access request (GIPA) — speed camera tolerance & site data To the Access to Information / GIPA Officer, Under the Government Information (Public Access) Act 2009 (NSW), I request (informal release preferred; if declined, treat as a formal application and advise the $30 fee): 1. The speed enforcement threshold/tolerance applied before a FIXED camera, and before a MOBILE camera, issues an infringement (the km/h or % over the posted limit). 2. For the 10 highest-revenue fixed speed and red-light camera locations in the most recent financial year: the infringements issued and revenue raised by year (last 5 years), and the recorded injury and fatal crash history at each site for the 5 years BEFORE the camera was installed and for each year SINCE. 3. The site-selection justification / business case used to approve each of those cameras. Electronic form (spreadsheet if available). [Your name] · [contact] · [date]
Template 9 — Cabin-camera accuracy & the contract
The false-positive rate no one publishes, plus how the operator is paid (see Cabin Cameras, Contracts). To accessapplications@transport.nsw.gov.au.
Send to: accessapplications@transport.nsw.gov.au (Transport for NSW)
Subject: Informal access request (GIPA) — phone/seatbelt camera accuracy & contract
To the Access to Information / GIPA Officer,
Under the Government Information (Public Access) Act 2009 (NSW), for the last
3 financial years for mobile-phone and seatbelt detection cameras:
1. The number of vehicle images captured; the number AI-flagged as possible
offences; and the number REJECTED at human review (i.e. the machine's
false-positive count or rate).
2. The number of penalty notices issued; the number challenged/reviewed;
and the number WITHDRAWN or refunded, with the total value.
3. The retention/deletion policy for non-offence ("innocent") images.
4. The current contract(s) with the camera operator (Acusensus), in
particular the clauses setting out HOW the operator is paid — per hour,
fixed fee, or linked to the number/value of detections — and the total
contract value.
Where commercial-in-confidence is claimed over the payment structure, please
release those clauses with only genuine pricing detail redacted, and state
the public-interest reasoning.
[Your name] · [contact] · [date]
Template 10 — Total camera revenue & withdrawal rates
The full revenue picture and how often fines are quietly reversed (see The Money, Errors). To Revenue NSW via gipa@customerservice.nsw.gov.au.
Send to: gipa@customerservice.nsw.gov.au (Revenue NSW, via Dept of Customer Service) Subject: Informal access request (GIPA) — camera fine revenue & reviews To the GIPA Team, Under the Government Information (Public Access) Act 2009 (NSW), for each of the last 5 financial years: 1. Total penalty-notice revenue from CAMERA-detected offences, split by type (fixed speed, mobile speed, red-light, mobile-phone, seatbelt, average / point-to-point speed). 2. The number of penalty notices issued, by type. 3. The number for which a review was requested; the number withdrawn, waived or refunded; and the total dollar value withdrawn. 4. The number that escalated to enforcement action (e.g. licence or registration sanction). Electronic form (spreadsheet). [Your name] · [contact] · [date]
Template 11 — Victoria: revenue, tolerance & siting
The Victorian versions of the same questions, including the 2026 VAGO "15 of 33" siting gap. To foi@transport.vic.gov.au (Dept of Transport & Planning); cc foi@police.vic.gov.au for enforcement/siting.
Send to: foi@transport.vic.gov.au (Dept of Transport & Planning) Cc: foi@police.vic.gov.au (Victoria Police — enforcement & siting) Subject: FOI request — road-safety camera revenue, tolerance and site selection To the FOI Officer, Under the Freedom of Information Act 1982 (Vic), for the last 3 financial years: 1. Road-safety-camera fine revenue by camera type. 2. The enforcement tolerance applied before a camera issues an infringement. 3. For distracted-driver and seatbelt cameras: images captured, AI-flagged, rejected at human review (false positives), fines issued, reviewed and withdrawn. 4. The crash history and site-selection basis for the AI camera sites examined in the 2026 VAGO audit (the finding that 15 of 33 sites had no crash record). I request a fee waiver on public-interest grounds. Electronic copy. [Your name] · [contact] · [date]
Template 12 — Queensland: CDOP revenue & spending
Where Queensland's ~$466m camera haul goes, and whether its cameras sit at crashes. Lodge via the e-RTI portal at rti.qld.gov.au; enquiries contactrti@tmr.qld.gov.au — ask for free "administrative access" first.
Send to: Qld Transport & Main Roads — e-RTI portal (rti.qld.gov.au, approved form); enquiries contactrti@tmr.qld.gov.au (ask for free "administrative access" first) Subject: RTI / administrative access — Camera Detected Offence Program To the RTI Team, Under the Right to Information Act 2009 (Qld) — or by administrative access if available — for the last 5 financial years: 1. Camera Detected Offence Program (CDOP) revenue by camera type. 2. The road-safety expenditure that revenue funded, itemised by program. 3. The speed enforcement tolerance applied before a camera issues a fine. 4. For the 10 highest-revenue camera sites, the recorded crash history for the 5 years before and after installation. Electronic form (spreadsheet if available). [Your name] · [contact] · [date]
Where to send it — verified contacts
The addresses below were checked against each agency's own page. Where an agency prefers a portal or a mandatory form, that's noted — using it is the safest route.
| Agency (what they hold) | Send to | Fee |
|---|---|---|
| Transport for NSW — cameras, the road-safety fund GIPA | accessapplications@transport.nsw.gov.au | free informal / $30 formal |
| Revenue NSW — fine revenue, penalty notices GIPA | gipa@customerservice.nsw.gov.au (via Dept of Customer Service) | free informal / $30 formal |
| NSW Police Force — mobile cameras, ANPR GIPA | Online GIPA portal at police.nsw.gov.au; enquiries iau@police.nsw.gov.au | $30 formal |
| Dept of Transport & Planning (VIC) — VicRoads / cameras FOI | foi@transport.vic.gov.au · portal online.foi.vic.gov.au | ~$34.50 (waivable) |
| Victoria Police — enforcement FOI | foi@police.vic.gov.au | ~$34.50 (waivable) |
| Transport & Main Roads (QLD) — camera program RTI | e-RTI portal rti.qld.gov.au (approved form); enquiries contactrti@tmr.qld.gov.au | ask for free "administrative access"; ~$59.60 formal |
| Queensland Police RTI | e-RTI portal rti.qld.gov.au; rti@police.qld.gov.au | as above |
| Dept of Infrastructure / BITRE — national crash data FOI (Cth) | foi@infrastructure.gov.au | no fee — a plain email is enough |
- NSW (GIPA) — ask for informal release first (free); if refused, a formal application is $30 and the agency has 20 working days. Oversight: IPC NSW.
- VIC (FOI) — ~$34.50 application fee, waivable for hardship or public interest; 30 days. Oversight: OVIC.
- QLD (RTI) — a formal request needs the approved RTI form and card payment via the e-RTI portal; but ask the RTI team for free "administrative access" first. Oversight: OIC Qld.
- Federal (FOI) — no application fee, a plain email works, 30 days. Oversight: OAIC.
- SA / WA / TAS / ACT / NT — each has its own FOI/RTI Act; adapt any template above and search "[state] FOI request".
Fees change on 1 July each year (VIC/QLD) — confirm the current figure on the agency page. Always ask for a fee waiver on public-interest grounds. Got something back? Send it in via whistle@theradicalparty.com or GitHub — we'll add it, with credit or in confidence.
Got a fine? Know your moves
- Request a review. Every state lets you ask the issuing agency to review a fine — cite faulty signage, calibration doubt, or exceptional circumstances (see Errors: a camera certificate is not automatic guilt).
- Elect to have it heard in court if you genuinely dispute it — the prosecution must prove the offence, including that the device was operating correctly.
- Can't afford it? In NSW, ask about a Work and Development Order; other states have hardship schemes. Don't let an unpaid fine snowball into a licence loss (see Punishing the Poor).
- Private "parking fine"? On private land it's usually a breach-of-contract invoice, not a government fine — often an unenforceable penalty (see the parking racket). Get advice before paying.
General information only — not legal advice. Rules and deadlines differ by state and change over time; check your official state authority and consider free community legal help before acting.